Aubrey or Butker: Who Should Be Your Fantasy Kicker?

November 6, 2024 By Alisson

The fantasy football season is upon us, and while the focus often rests on quarterbacks, running backs, and wide receivers, the kicker position can be the difference between victory and defeat. Choosing the right kicker is crucial. This article delves into the Aubrey Or Butker debate, offering insights to help you make the informed decision for your fantasy team.

Kicking Consistency: Aubrey vs. Butker

When choosing a kicker, consistency is key. Both Harrison Butker and Daniel Carlson (often referred to as “Aubrey” due to his resemblance to the musician Drake, whose real name is Aubrey Drake Graham) have proven track records. Butker, with his powerful leg, is known for long field goals. Carlson, on the other hand, demonstrates remarkable accuracy, consistently making shorter kicks. So, the question becomes: do you prioritize boom potential or reliable points?

Butker’s past performances suggest a higher ceiling, capable of racking up significant points in games with favorable matchups. However, he’s also shown inconsistency, leaving fantasy managers frustrated at times. Carlson, while lacking the same explosive potential, provides a safer floor, consistently delivering points week after week.

For those seeking a more stable option, Carlson might be the better choice. His consistency provides a predictable source of points, minimizing the risk of a goose egg in your lineup.

Aubrey vs. Butker Field Goal Comparison

Team Context: Impact on Kicker Performance

Analyzing team context is crucial when comparing kickers. The Chiefs’ high-powered offense often puts Butker in scoring positions, leading to more field goal attempts. However, their tendency to score touchdowns can sometimes limit his opportunities. The Raiders, while not as consistently explosive, still provide Carlson with ample scoring opportunities.

Considering the offensive dynamics of both teams, it’s important to evaluate which kicker will have more chances to put points on the board. While Butker benefits from the Chiefs’ offensive prowess, Carlson’s situation with the Raiders may offer a more balanced approach, with a mix of field goals and extra points.

Chiefs and Raiders Red Zone Efficiency

2023 Projections: Predicting Future Performance

Projecting kicker performance is inherently difficult, but analyzing past trends, team changes, and potential matchups can offer valuable insight. Early projections suggest that both Butker and Carlson are expected to be top-10 kickers. However, the gap between them might be smaller than you think.

While Butker might have the edge in terms of upside, Carlson’s consistent performance could make him the more valuable fantasy asset in the long run. Ultimately, the decision between Aubrey or Butker hinges on your risk tolerance and fantasy scoring system.

Projected Fantasy Points 2023 Kickers

Conclusion: Making the Final Decision

Choosing between Aubrey (Carlson) and Butker comes down to your fantasy strategy. If you prefer consistency and a reliable floor, Carlson is your guy. If you’re willing to gamble on a boom-or-bust kicker with the potential for huge weeks, Butker might be worth the risk. Consider your team’s needs, scoring system, and risk tolerance before making your final decision. Choosing the right kicker, even in the Aubrey or Butker debate, can be a game-changer.

FAQs

Who has a stronger leg, Aubrey or Butker? Butker is known for his powerful leg and long field goals.
Who is more consistent, Aubrey or Butker? Carlson (Aubrey) generally exhibits greater consistency.
Which team offers more scoring opportunities for their kicker? The Chiefs’ offense often puts Butker in scoring positions.
Who is projected to score more fantasy points in 2023? Projections are close, but slightly favor Butker.
Which kicker is better for my fantasy team? It depends on your team needs and risk tolerance.
Does Aubrey really look like Drake? The resemblance is striking, leading to the nickname.
Are there other good kicker options besides Aubrey and Butker? Yes, there are several other reliable kickers to consider.