Dustin Hopkins or Brandon Aubrey: A Kicking Conundrum in Dallas

The Dallas Cowboys, a team known for their offensive prowess, find themselves in an interesting predicament as they head into the 2023 season: choosing between kickers Dustin Hopkins and Brandon Aubrey. This isn’t about replacing a legend, but rather finding a reliable option to secure those crucial extra points and field goals.

Dustin Hopkins and Brandon Aubrey Kicking Comparison

Experience vs Potential: A Tale of Two Kickers

Dustin Hopkins, a seasoned veteran, brings a wealth of experience to the table. Having played for the Redskins, Chargers, and even a brief stint with the Cowboys in 2022, Hopkins boasts a respectable career field goal percentage hovering around 84%. He’s proven his ability to handle the pressure and deliver in clutch situations.

Brandon Aubrey, on the other hand, is the young gun looking to make his mark. With a background in soccer and a stint in the USFL, Aubrey possesses a powerful leg and raw talent. His journey to the NFL has been unconventional, but his potential is undeniable.

Brandon Aubrey Kicking in the USFL

Preseason Performance: The Battle Heats Up

The preseason provided a glimpse into the strengths and weaknesses of both kickers. Hopkins, known for his consistency, unfortunately battled through an injury, limiting his opportunities to showcase his abilities. Aubrey, eager to seize the moment, stepped up and delivered a solid preseason performance, connecting on all his field goal attempts.

The Case for Dustin Hopkins: Reliability and Experience

Hopkins offers the Cowboys a sense of security and familiarity. His track record speaks for itself, and his ability to perform under pressure cannot be overstated. While his age might be a factor, Hopkins has demonstrated his ability to maintain a high level of play.

“Dustin’s experience is invaluable,” says former NFL kicker and ESPN analyst, Jay Feely. “He understands the nuances of the game, and his consistency can be a huge asset for a team like the Cowboys with playoff aspirations.”

Dustin Hopkins Celebrates a Game-Winning Field Goal

The Case for Brandon Aubrey: Potential and Upside

Aubrey represents the future. His strong leg and accuracy offer the Cowboys a glimpse of what could be a long and successful career. His limited experience might be a concern for some, but his preseason performance suggests he’s ready to rise to the occasion.

“Aubrey has all the tools to be a star in this league,” says former NFL scout and current NFL Network analyst, Daniel Jeremiah. “His potential is through the roof, and the Cowboys might have found a diamond in the rough.”

The Verdict: A Difficult Decision Looms

Choosing between experience and potential is never easy. The Cowboys must weigh the reliability and consistency of Hopkins against the raw talent and upside of Aubrey. The decision could ultimately come down to who the coaching staff trusts more in high-pressure situations.

One thing is for sure: the kicking competition in Dallas will be one to watch as the 2023 NFL season unfolds.