The fantasy football draft season is upon us, and with it comes the annual dilemma of choosing the right players for your team. While often overlooked, a reliable kicker can be the difference between a win and a loss. This year, two kickers stand out as popular choices: Jake Moody and Jake Elliott. Both kickers have shown promise and consistency, leaving fantasy owners with a tough decision. So, who should you draft for your fantasy team: Jake Moody Or Jake Elliott? Let’s delve into a head-to-head comparison to help you make the optimal choice.
Jake Moody: The Young Gun with a Powerful Leg
Drafted by the San Francisco 49ers in the third round of the 2023 NFL Draft, Jake Moody was brought in to fill the shoes of veteran kicker Robbie Gould. Known for his powerful leg and accuracy, Moody was a standout at the University of Michigan, earning the Lou Groza Award for the nation’s best kicker in 2021. Moody possesses a cannon for a leg, consistently hitting from long distances, which translates well to fantasy points.
However, the rookie kicker does come with some concerns. Primarily, his performance in high-pressure situations is yet to be tested at the NFL level. Additionally, playing for a run-first offense like the 49ers could potentially limit his field goal opportunities.
Jake Elliott: The Proven Veteran with a Reliable Track Record
Jake Elliott, the seasoned veteran, has been a reliable kicker for the Philadelphia Eagles since 2017. He played a pivotal role in their Super Bowl LII victory, showcasing his clutch performance capabilities. Elliott benefits from a high-powered Eagles offense, providing ample scoring opportunities and fantasy points. His experience and consistency make him a safe and reliable pick.
Despite his experience, Elliott’s accuracy from long range has been questioned in the past. While he delivers consistently from short to mid-range, his field goal percentage dips slightly beyond 50 yards.
The Verdict: Weighing the Options
Both Jake Moody and Jake Elliott offer enticing potential for fantasy football owners. Moody’s booming leg and potential for long field goals are attractive, but his lack of experience raises some concerns. Elliott, on the other hand, provides the reassurance of consistency and a high-scoring offense.
Ultimately, the decision comes down to your risk tolerance and draft strategy. If you’re seeking a high-risk, high-reward kicker with a strong leg, Moody is your guy. If you prefer a safe and steady option with a proven track record, Elliott is the better choice.
Consider your team’s needs, your league’s scoring system, and your personal draft philosophy before making your decision. Whichever kicker you choose, we wish you the best of luck in your fantasy football season!