Choosing between Travis Etienne and Najee Harris for your fantasy football team can feel like splitting hairs. Both are young, talented running backs with high draft capital and the potential to carry an offense. But digging into their 2022 seasons, upcoming schedules, and offensive line play reveals key differences that can make or break your fantasy season.
Explosiveness vs. Volume: A Tale of Two Backfields
Travis Etienne exploded onto the scene in 2022, showcasing the electrifying speed and big-play ability that made him a first-round pick. He averaged a stellar 5.4 yards per carry, consistently ripping off chunk plays and finding the endzone, ending the season with over 1,100 rushing yards and seven touchdowns.
Najee Harris, on the other hand, is the epitome of a workhorse back. He’s averaged over 300 touches in each of his first two seasons, proving his durability and dependability in a Pittsburgh offense that leans heavily on the run game. While his 3.9 yards per carry in 2022 left much to be desired, his ten touchdowns demonstrate his red zone prowess.
So, which approach is more valuable in fantasy football: Etienne’s home run potential or Harris’s consistent volume?
Offensive Line Play: A Key Factor in 2023?
Analyzing offensive line play is crucial when evaluating running backs. A strong line can create running lanes and provide quarterbacks with time to throw, ultimately boosting a running back’s production.
Pittsburgh Steelers Offensive Line
The Steelers offensive line struggled mightily in 2022, ranking among the league’s worst in run blocking. While they’ve made offseason improvements, it remains to be seen if they can elevate Harris to his full potential.
The Jaguars, on the other hand, boast an improved offensive line with the addition of veteran Brandon Scherff. This bodes well for Etienne, who thrives on finding open space and breaking tackles in the second level.
Schedule Strength and Fantasy Implications
Fantasy football isn’t just about individual talent; it’s about maximizing points against favorable matchups. Examining the strength of schedule for both Etienne and Harris can provide valuable insights for your draft strategy.
NFL 2023 Schedule Strength
The Jaguars face a relatively easier schedule in 2023, with matchups against weaker run defenses like the Texans and Colts. This could translate into more opportunities for Etienne to rack up yards and touchdowns.
The Steelers, however, face a tougher slate, particularly within their own division. The Ravens and Bengals boast formidable defenses that could limit Harris’s upside on a weekly basis.
The Verdict: Finding the Right Fit for Your Fantasy Team
Ultimately, the decision between Travis Etienne and Najee Harris depends on your fantasy football philosophy and risk tolerance. If you prioritize explosiveness, big-play potential, and a higher ceiling, Etienne is your guy. If you prefer a proven workhorse with a safe floor and touchdown upside, Harris is the more conservative choice.
Remember, fantasy football is a marathon, not a sprint. Consider your league’s scoring system, your team’s needs, and the other players available when making your draft decisions.