Ty Chandler or Derrick Henry: Which Running Back Should You Draft?

The 2023 fantasy football draft season is upon us, and running back is always a hotly contested position. Two names consistently popping up in mock drafts and discussions are Ty Chandler and Derrick Henry. Both offer intriguing potential, but their situations and styles differ significantly. So, who should you target for your fantasy team: the explosive young talent or the established workhorse?

Analyzing the Skillsets

Derrick Henry is a known commodity in the NFL. He’s a physical specimen, a bruising runner who punishes defenders and wears them down over the game. Henry thrives on volume and consistently ranks among the league leaders in carries. He’s a true three-down back, capable of handling a massive workload and delivering consistent production. However, at 29 years old and with a lot of mileage on his legs, the question arises: can he maintain this elite level of play?

On the other hand, Ty Chandler presents a different profile. He is a dynamic and versatile back with exceptional speed and agility. While he may not possess Henry’s raw power, Chandler excels at finding holes, making defenders miss, and breaking big plays. His pass-catching ability adds another dimension to his game, making him a valuable asset in PPR leagues. The main concern with Chandler is his opportunity. Sharing the backfield with Dalvin Cook, his touches are likely to be limited.

Statistical Comparison

Looking at their 2022 seasons, the statistical differences are stark. Henry carried the ball 349 times for 1,538 yards and 13 touchdowns, further cementing his reputation as a fantasy football juggernaut. Chandler, in a limited role, had 50 carries for 283 yards and two touchdowns, showcasing flashes of his potential. However, it’s crucial to consider the context. Henry was the undisputed workhorse in Tennessee, while Chandler was primarily a change-of-pace back.

Injury History and Durability

Durability is a critical factor in fantasy football, and here’s where Henry’s demanding running style raises concerns. He has suffered significant injuries in the past, notably a foot injury in 2021 that sidelined him for a significant portion of the season. Chandler, while relatively inexperienced, has a clean bill of health, which adds to his appeal, especially in later rounds.

The Verdict: Who to Draft?

The choice between Ty Chandler and Derrick Henry ultimately depends on your draft strategy and risk tolerance. If you’re looking for a proven, high-volume back who can carry your team week in and week out, Henry is your guy, despite the risk of injury. However, if you miss out on the early-round running backs and need a high-upside player in the middle rounds, Chandler’s explosiveness and potential for a larger role make him a fantastic pick.

Don’t forget to consider the other players available at their respective Average Draft Positions (ADPs) and the specific needs of your fantasy team. Both Chandler and Henry can be valuable assets, but understanding their strengths, weaknesses, and potential impact on your roster is crucial for making the right decision on draft day.